According to a review article in Sports Medicine-Open, an age-related decline in testosterone levels in men is associated with decreased strength, endurance, and altered body composition. Testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) demonstrates efficacy in elevating testosterone levels, but its benefits for healthy aging males remain under investigation. Conversely, exercise training, particularly resistance and aerobic modalities, offers well-established benefits for this population. Exercise not only promotes muscle growth, cardiovascular health, and cognitive function, but also exhibits a positive influence on testosterone levels A holistic approach that integrates a comprehensive exercise program, a balanced diet, sufficient sleep, and stress management appears most effective for optimizing testosterone levels and promoting overall well-being in aging men.

Key Findings

1. Testosterone Decline and Aging: Testosterone levels naturally decrease with age in men, leading to potential changes in strength, endurance, and body composition.

2. Testosterone Replacement Therapy (TRT): TRT can elevate testosterone levels, but the benefits for healthy aging men are debatable. High-dose TRT may increase muscle mass when combined with exercise, but carries risks like heart disease, stroke, and prostate cancer.

3. Exercise: The Champion for Healthy Aging: Regular exercise, particularly resistance training and aerobic activity offers numerous benefits for aging men. Resistance training builds muscle and bone density, while aerobic exercise improves cardiovascular health, endurance, and cognitive function.

4. Exercise and Testosterone: Exercise can positively impact testosterone levels. Resistance training can lead to short-term spikes, and consistent exercise training can help maintain testosterone within a healthy range as men age.

5. TRT vs. Exercise: Weighing the Evidence: While TRT might increase muscle mass, the potential health risks outweigh the benefits for most men. Exercise offers a safer and more comprehensive approach to promoting health and well-being.

6. Optimizing Your Exercise Routine: Focus on resistance training 2-3 times per week, targeting major muscle groups with challenging exercises. Engage in moderate-intensity aerobic activity for at least 150 minutes weekly or vigorous activity for 75 minutes. Consult a healthcare professional to design a safe and effective program.

7. Beyond the Basics: Advanced Strategies: For deeper optimization, consider progressive overload in resistance training, prioritize compound exercises and higher training intensity, and focus on post-workout nutrition with a balance of protein and carbohydrates. Additionally, prioritize quality sleep, manage stress, maintain a healthy diet, and monitor your progress. Remember, consult a doctor before implementing advanced strategies or making significant lifestyle changes.

The Effects of Testosterone and Exercise on Aging Men: What Does the Science Say?

As men age, they often experience declines in muscle mass, strength, and overall fitness. Two potential interventions to combat these age-related changes are testosterone (T) supplementation and exercise. But which approach is more effective? And could combining testosterone and exercise provide even greater benefits?

A comprehensive review published in 2024 examined the current scientific evidence on the effects of testosterone treatment, exercise, and their combination in middle-aged and older men. Let's break down the key findings and what they mean for men looking to stay fit and healthy as they age.

The Testosterone Decline

It's well established that testosterone levels tend to decrease as men get older, especially after age 40. By age 70, many men have testosterone levels significantly lower than younger adults. However, it's not entirely clear if this decline is an inevitable part of aging or more related to the accumulation of health issues like obesity and chronic diseases over time.

Interestingly, some healthy men aged 40-69 can maintain stable testosterone levels over several years. But after 70, there's stronger evidence of impaired testicular hormone production in many men.

The Potential of Testosterone Treatment

Given the natural decline in testosterone, there's been growing interest in testosterone replacement therapy as a potential "anti-aging" strategy for older men. Prescriptions for testosterone increased dramatically in the early 2000s, though they've since decreased somewhat.

The review examined numerous studies on testosterone supplementation in middle-aged and older men. Here's what the evidence shows:

Lean Body Mass: Testosterone treatment does appear to increase lean body mass in older men, with an average gain of about 2.2 kg across studies. This effect seems to be dose-dependent, with higher doses leading to greater increases.

Strength: The results for strength are more mixed. Some studies show modest improvements in measures like grip strength, while others find no significant benefit. Overall, the effect of testosterone on strength in older men appears to be small to moderate at best.

Aerobic Fitness: There's limited evidence that testosterone meaningfully improves aerobic fitness in healthy older men. Some studies show small benefits, but these are often due to preventing age-related declines rather than actual improvements.

The Power of Exercise

In contrast to the somewhat mixed results for testosterone, the evidence for exercise is much more robust:

Lean Body Mass: Resistance training studies in men over 50 show average lean mass gains of about 1.1 kg over 20 weeks. While slightly less than testosterone treatment alone, it's still a significant improvement.

Strength: The evidence for strength gains with exercise is overwhelming. A review of 73 trials found that progressive resistance training has a large positive effect on muscle strength in older adults. Improvements of 24-29% in major muscle groups are typical.

Aerobic Fitness: Studies consistently show that exercise training can improve VO2 peak (a key measure of aerobic fitness) by 10-32% in older men. These are substantial gains that have real-world impact on health and longevity.

Combining Testosterone and Exercise

Given that both testosterone and exercise show some benefits, researchers have also investigated whether combining the two approaches could provide additive effects. The results are intriguing:

Lean Body Mass: Some evidence suggests that combining testosterone and exercise may lead to greater gains in lean mass than either approach alone. This effect seems more pronounced in younger men and with higher testosterone doses.

Strength: For physiological doses of testosterone (aimed at bringing levels to the normal range), there doesn't appear to be an additive benefit for strength when combined with exercise. Exercise alone seems to be the primary driver of strength gains.

Aerobic Fitness: Similarly, adding testosterone to an exercise program doesn't seem to provide additional aerobic fitness benefits beyond what exercise alone can achieve.

The TEX Trial: A Direct Comparison

One of the most informative studies in this area is the recent Testosterone and Exercise (TEX) trial. This study directly compared the effects of testosterone treatment, exercise, and their combination in men aged 50-70 with low-normal testosterone levels.

Key findings from TEX:

1. Testosterone alone increased total, leg, and arm lean body mass.

2. Exercise alone improved all strength measures and increased VO2 peak by 13%.

3. The combination of testosterone and exercise had additive effects for lean body mass in specific regions (leg and arm) but not overall.

4. Adding testosterone to exercise did not provide additional benefits for strength or aerobic fitness compared to exercise alone.

These results reinforce the idea that while testosterone can help with lean mass, exercise is the primary driver of improvements in strength and aerobic fitness.

Safety Considerations

While higher doses of testosterone might have larger effects on muscle, this has to be balanced against potential risks. Some studies have raised concerns about cardiovascular side effects with testosterone treatment, especially at higher doses in older men.

However, recent large-scale trials provide some reassurance. The TRAVERSE trial, which included over 5,000 men aged 45-80, found no increased risk of major cardiovascular events with testosterone treatment over an average of 22 months.

Still, it's crucial to note that testosterone replacement should only be considered under medical supervision for men with clinically low levels, not as a general anti-aging strategy.

Practical Implications: What Should Aging Men Do?

Based on the current evidence, here are some key takeaways for middle-aged and older men looking to maintain their health and fitness:

1. Exercise should be the first-line strategy. Both resistance and aerobic exercise provide substantial benefits for lean mass, strength, and overall fitness. These improvements have real-world impacts on health, longevity, and quality of life.

2. Consistency is key. Many of the positive study results come from supervised, center-based exercise programs. The challenge is maintaining a consistent exercise routine in real-world settings. Finding enjoyable activities and building sustainable habits is crucial.

3. Testosterone is not a magic bullet. While it can help increase lean mass, testosterone supplementation alone is not likely to dramatically improve strength or fitness in otherwise healthy older men.

4. Consider testosterone only if levels are clinically low. Testosterone replacement therapy should be reserved for men with diagnosed hypogonadism (low testosterone production) under medical supervision.

5. Combine approaches for optimal results. For men who do require testosterone treatment, combining it with exercise is likely to provide the greatest overall benefits.

6. Focus on overall health. Maintaining a healthy weight, eating a balanced diet, managing stress, and getting adequate sleep can all help support healthy testosterone levels and overall well-being as you age.

The Bigger Picture: Successful Aging

While much of the research focuses on specific physical measures like muscle mass and strength, it's important to consider the broader context of healthy aging. The improvements in body composition, strength, and aerobic fitness that come from exercise (and potentially testosterone in some cases) have far-reaching implications:

• Increased independence and ability to perform daily activities

• Reduced risk of falls and fractures

• Better cardiovascular health

• Improved metabolic health and reduced risk of type 2 diabetes

• Enhanced cognitive function and mental well-being

• Potentially reduced all-cause mortality risk

By focusing on maintaining physical fitness through regular exercise, older men can set themselves up for a higher quality of life in their later years.

The Future of Aging Research

While this review provides valuable insights, there's still much to learn about optimizing health and fitness in aging men. Some areas for future research include:

1. Longer-term studies on the safety and efficacy of testosterone treatment in older men

2. Investigations into personalized exercise and hormone protocols based on individual factors

3. Exploration of other potential interventions to support healthy aging (e.g., nutrition, sleep optimization)

4. Better understanding of the molecular mechanisms behind age-related physical decline

Conclusion

The science is clear: exercise is the most effective intervention for maintaining strength, fitness, and overall health as men age. While testosterone treatment can provide some benefits, particularly for lean body mass, it should be considered only in specific clinical situations.

For the vast majority of men, a consistent exercise routine that includes both resistance and aerobic components is the best strategy for staying fit and healthy into older age. Combine this with other healthy lifestyle habits, and you'll be setting yourself up for successful aging and a high quality of life in your later years.

Remember, it's never too late to start prioritizing your fitness. Whether you're 40, 60, or 80, your body can still adapt and improve with regular exercise. So lace up those sneakers, grab those weights, and invest in your future health – your older self will thank you!

Related Articles:

Best Exercise for Blood Sugar: Intensity & Type Compared (Science-Backed Guide)

Journal Reference

Green, D.J., Chasland, L.C., Yeap, B.B. et al. Comparing the Impacts of Testosterone and Exercise on Lean Body Mass, Strength and Aerobic Fitness in Aging Men. Sports Med - Open 10, 30 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40798-024-00703-x

Disclaimer

The information on this website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.