Optimizing Fat Loss: Impact of HIIT and MICT on Fat Oxidation in Obese Adults

This research, published in the Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness, explores the effectiveness of HIIT (High-Intensity Interval Training) and MICT (Moderate-Intensity Continuous Training) for fat loss in overweight and obese adults. It focuses on maximizing fat oxidation (MFO), a key factor in weight management. The analysis of 13 studies with over 500 participants reveals both HIIT and MICT significantly increase MFO compared to no exercise. MICT showed a larger increase (0.1 g/min) than HIIT (0.07 g/min). Interestingly, in obese individuals, there wasn't a significant difference in MFO change between HIIT and MICT. The study suggests MICT with moderate intensity (65-70% VO2peak) for 60 minutes, 3 times a week, is optimal for MFO in overweight/obese adults. However, more research is needed for standardized HIIT protocols.

Key Points

1. HIIT and MICT Efficacy: This meta-analysis unequivocally establishes the effectiveness of both high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) in improving maximal fat oxidation (MFO) in overweight and obese adults.

2. Critical Moderators: Exercise intensity, mode, BMI, and VO2peak emerge as pivotal moderators influencing MFO during MICT. Understanding these factors is key to tailoring interventions for optimal results.

3. HIIT Controversies: While study findings support the positive impact of HIIT on MFO, the existing literature's conflicting reports highlight the need for standardized protocols and further research to unlock HIIT's full potential.

4. Sensitivity Analysis Insights: Identifying specific studies as sources of heterogeneity underscores the importance of meticulous study design evaluation. Methodological variations must be considered for future research endeavours.

5. Practical Considerations: Crafting personalized exercise interventions involves balancing HIIT and MICT benefits, participant preferences, and non-exercise strategies. This nuanced approach is essential for addressing the multifaceted challenge of overweight and obesity.

This meta-analysis systematically reviewed the chronic effects of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) on maximal fat oxidation (MFO) in overweight and obese adults. It also explored factors influencing MFO and its dose-response relationship with these exercise modalities. Thirteen studies, involving 519 overweight and obese participants (136 HIIT, 235 MICT, and 148 control), were included in this review. Both HIIT and MICT were found to significantly improve MFO compared to no exercise. HIIT showed a statistically significant favorable effect on MFO with a mean difference (MD) of 0.07 (95% CI [0.03 to 0.11]; I² = 0%). Similarly, MICT also displayed a significant positive impact on MFO with an MD of 0.10 (95% CI [0.06 to 0.15]; I² = 95%). Although HIIT and MICT both improved MFO, a direct comparison between them indicated no significant difference in the magnitude of MFO change (MD = 0.01; 95% CI [-0.02 to 0.04]; I² = 64%).

Subgroup and regression analyses highlighted key moderators of the effect of MICT on MFO. These moderators included exercise intensity (Fatmax vs. non-Fatmax), exercise mode, body mass index (BMI), and peak oxygen consumption (VO₂peak). The analyses suggested that MICT at 65-70% VO₂peak, performed three times a week for 60 minutes per session, optimized MFO in overweight and obese adults. However, due to the limited number of studies and the heterogeneity of HIIT protocols, the authors could not provide conclusive recommendations regarding the most effective HIIT protocol for improving MFO. The authors concluded that both HIIT and MICT are effective at enhancing MFO in overweight and obese adults, with no significant differences in their effectiveness. MICT appears to be better characterized in terms of its optimal intensity and duration for maximizing fat oxidation. HIIT, while effective, needs more research to determine the best protocols for optimizing MFO in this population. Both exercise types can be valuable tools for improving metabolic health and managing obesity, as they enhance the body’s ability to oxidize fat, a crucial factor in weight management and reducing metabolic risk.

The Significance of Maximal Fat Oxidation (MFO)

Ectopic fat deposition, a hallmark of overweight and obesity, is intricately linked to metabolic diseases, including insulin resistance, posing a substantial risk to cardiovascular health. Maximal fat oxidation (MFO) emerges as a crucial parameter in the quest for effective weight management. MFO, determined by factors such as age, gender, training background, BMI, exercise mode, and nutritional status, plays a pivotal role in metabolic flexibility.

The Evolution of Fatmax and MFO Measurement

In the pursuit of accurate MFO measurement, the fitness community witnessed a significant development with Achten et al.'s introduction of "Fatmax" in 2001. The subsequent creation of a graded incremental load test enabled a more precise determination of Fatmax and MFO. Over the past two decades, these metrics have become indispensable in weight management, metabolic health, and personalized exercise interventions.

The Battle: HIIT vs. MICT

As the debate rages on regarding the efficacy of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) in improving MFO, a meta-analysis of thirteen studies sheds light on the matter. The inclusion of 519 overweight and obese subjects reveals compelling insights.

HIIT's Impact on MFO

This meta-analysis indicates a statistically significant favorable effect of HIIT on MFO compared to no training. The moderate increase in MFO (0.07 g/min) is deemed clinically significant, aligning with previous research suggesting any increase beyond 0.07 g/min as noteworthy.

MICT's Impact on MFO

MICT, too, displays a statistically significant favorable effect on MFO compared to no training, with a notably larger increase (0.10 g/min). This robust effect suggests the potency of MICT interventions for overweight and obese individuals.

Unveiling the Moderators

Delving into the nuances of MFO enhancement, subgroup and regression analyses highlight critical moderators. Exercise intensity, mode, BMI, and VO2peak significantly influence MICT on MFO. Intriguingly, direct comparisons between HIIT and MICT in obese individuals reveal no substantial difference in MFO change.

Recommendations for Optimal Results

In navigating the realm of exercise protocols, this meta-analysis proposes that MICT with an intensity of 65–70% VO2peak, performed thrice weekly for 60 minutes per session, optimizes MFO increases in overweight and obese adults. However, the lack of consensus on HIIT's impact prompts a call for further research and standardized protocols.

Practical Implications and Considerations

The study's outcomes have practical implications for devising personalized exercise interventions. Both HIIT and MICT emerge as effective tools, with considerations for individual preferences, time constraints, and long-term adherence. The study findings also underscore the importance of increasing VO2 max to enhance MFO gains.

Non-Exercise Strategies for Maximal Fat Oxidation

In addition to exercise interventions, this meta-analysis acknowledges the role of non-exercise strategies. Acute intake of fat, p-synephrine, and caffeine are identified as potential enhancers of MFO during exercise. Moreover, diurnal variations and temperature play pivotal roles in influencing MFO levels, offering avenues for optimization.

The Mechanisms Behind MICT-Induced MFO Increase

The literature suggests that MICT-induced enhancements in MFO stem from adaptations in adipose tissue lipolysis, NEFA transport to skeletal muscle, skeletal muscle NEFA uptake, muscle triglyceride lipolysis, and/or mitochondrial uptake of fatty acids. Understanding these mechanisms provides a foundation for tailoring MICT interventions for optimal results.

Subgroup Analysis

The intensity of MICT emerges as a crucial factor, with non-Fatmax MICT proving more effective in improving MFO than Fatmax. The debate on running versus cycling also takes center stage, revealing no significant difference in exercise-induced MFO increases. These revelations pave the way for more targeted and effective exercise prescriptions.

VO2Max as a Catalyst: Unveiling the Connection

Study results underscore the link between VO2max and MFO improvements with MICT. Individuals with higher VO2 max exhibit enhanced mitochondrial biogenesis capacity, tricarboxylic acid cycle activity, electron transport chain function, and fatty acid transport during exercise. This revelation provides a roadmap for maximizing MFO gains through targeted interventions.

HIIT vs. MICT: A Delicate Balance

As we delve into the comparative analysis of HIIT and MICT, the fine balance between physiological effects and participant preferences emerges. Time efficiency becomes a pivotal consideration, with HIIT standing out as a potentially time-efficient tool for increasing MFO. However, the challenges in its implementation, coupled with long-term adherence concerns, highlight the need for a nuanced approach in selecting the most suitable modality.

Charting the Course Ahead

In conclusion, this comprehensive meta-analysis navigates the complex landscape of MFO enhancement in overweight and obese adults. HIIT and MICT emerge as potent tools, each with its own unique merits and considerations. As we chart the course ahead, unlocking the full potential of exercise interventions requires continued research, standardized protocols, and a nuanced understanding of participant dynamics.

Reference Article

Mendelson, M., Chacaroun, S., Baillieul, S., Doutreleau, S., Guinot, M., Wuyam, B., Tamisier, R., Pépin, J., Estève, F., Tessier, D., Vergès, S., & Flore, P. (2022). Effects of high-intensity interval training on sustained reduction in cardiometabolic risk associated with overweight // obesity: A randomized trial. Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness, 20(2), 172-181. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesf.2022.03.001

Image credit:https://www.frontiersin.org/files/MyHome%20Article%20Library/431145/431145_Thumb_400.jpg

Related

https://healthnewstrend.com/the-transformative-power-of-hiit-for-overcoming-obesity

Medical Disclaimer

The information on this website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.